Posted by
Joel Gaines on Wednesday, January 16, 2008 10:15:35 AM
I know some of my opinions about Russian policies and the
over-bearing nature of Russian government organizations are met with
angst from people I respect - People who also know Russia. However, it
is difficult to argue the perception of instability in Russia, when the
current government takes archetypal soviet actions.
Beslan - 396 people killed, many of them school children held
hostage in a 3 day siege. I remember it well. I helped raise funds for
the victims.

The investigation was a sham - cloaked in secrecy. The survivors and
families of the victims have never received satisfaction as to what
occurred there. But, here is how they are treated.
From Siberian Light
True, under Russian law, such criticism of the President
is technically illegal - the law was amended in 2006 to bring public
slander of a government official within the legal definition of
extremism,
But has anyone considered whether this prosecution is actually in
the public interest? How will the Russian public be served by
prosecuting a protest group led by greiving mothers?
Surely (and assuming that Putin isn’t complicit), the most sensible
way forward for the Russian authorities is to accept that grief causes
mothers who have lost their children to lash out, and accept this as a
natural expression of their anguish?
Instead, by prosecuting these mothers as extremists all Russia does
is trivialize its, and the world’s, ongoing struggle against real
terrorists.
The Voice of Beslan published a letter in 2005, for which they will now be prosecuted.
addressed to "Everyone sympathetic to Beslan's tragedy"
and posted on the group's web site, says "none of the acts of terrorism
that occurred during Putin's presidency has been investigated properly"
and that Putin has become "the guarantor for the terrorists" by not
punishing senior officials for the botched Beslan rescue operation.
More than 330 people died, most as special forces tried to rescue them
during the final chaotic hours of the 2004 hostage taking at the Beslan
school.
"We are surprised to find out that our right to
demand a fair investigation of the Beslan tragedy has been declared
extremist," Voice of Beslan founder Ella Kesayeva said by telephone
from Vladikavkaz.
Kesayeva, whose daughter survived the attack, said
she had been summoned to appear in a Nazran court on Monday. She said
she had asked prosecutors to move the case to Vladikavkaz, where the
Voice of Beslan was registered before it was disbanded by North
Ossetia's Supreme Court last month in a separate lawsuit.
Vladislav Svetostov, a spokesman for a Nazran
prosecutor, declined to comment about the extremist case ahead of the
hearings. He defended the complaint, though, saying prosecutors in all
regions are supposed to monitor the media to make sure that nothing
illegal is published.
The Voice of Beslan was formed as a nongovernmental
organization to raise awareness about the attack two years ago.
Kesayeva led the group until the North Ossetian court upheld a lawsuit
by another NGO with the same name last month.
Kesayeva accused the authorities of using the latest lawsuit to try to silence critical Beslan residents.
Many of these family members of vicitms and victims themselves also
stood in 2004, blocking highways in North Ossetia - Alania to try to
get attention for the need for investigations into what sparked the
battle at Number One School. The Russian authorities in the region
responded unfavorably then too.
I too don't indict Putin on this issue directly, however he cannot
possibly be deaf to this . It makes no sense that the event which was
galvanizing with respect to Russia's stance on terrorism has no
attention from him. He appointed the commission which pushed this under
the carpet. This is a federal issue.
As for the treatment of the Mothers of Beslan, well I condemn that.
Their children paid the ultimate price for Russia's war in Chechnya -
Russia's war on terror. They deserve better.